Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery: The Best of Amish Goods

I think we all can agree that Ohio Amish Country has some of the best food and baked goods in Ohio. Starting our trip off with a stop at Hershberger’s Farm in Holmes County was ideal. It introduced us to the warm and welcoming atmosphere in Ohio Amish Country and a peek into what was in store for the next three days.

During our drive from Michigan to Millersburg, Ohio, we viewed rolling hills, Amish buggies and scenic countryside. We’ve highlighted the best food, hikes, theater plays, museums, entertainment, shops and restaurants in our guide to experiencing a Magical Winter Getaway in Ohio Amish County.

Apple Cider Slushies at Hershberger’s

On top of the list of our favorite stops was Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery, which we visited in December.

What To Expect at Hershberger’s

Whether you are stopping to grab apples, buy quality made goods, visit furry friends at the petting farm, or are looking to enjoy a day in the farm fresh air with your friends and family, Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery is the perfect location to experience an Amish working farm.

Stop by and enjoy their open-fire kettle corn, fresh produce, apple cider slushies, or some freshly baked goodies from the bakery. The sights, smells, tastes and fun are plentiful. Hershberger's Farm and Bakery provides a glimpse into a working Amish farm. It's a delightful experience with abundant family fun all year long but especially in the summer or fall.

Where to Start

When you first arrive it may be difficult for you to choose where to begin… the farm or bakery?

Freshly Prepared Kettle Corn

Open Fire Kettle Corn

The smell of fresh kettle corn will draw you toward the bakery as soon as you arrive. Watch as an Amish man prepares the kettle corn over an open-fire. Grab some to eat now or for the drive home.

The Bakery

Inside the bakery you can select from a variety of apples, fresh vegetables and produce. The best Amish canned strawberry jams, apple butters, and preserves will tempt you as you peruse the store. Snack mixes, grocery items, fresh baked pies, pastries, donuts, meats and cheeses are all available. They do accept credit cards, which is a good thing because you won't leave empty handed.

Fry Pies

Delicious Fry Pies come in 13 different flavors

One specific item you must try are their delicious Fry Pies. These half-moon-shaped pastries are stuffed with fruit filling and come in 13 delicious flavors. Apple, peach, raspberry, and chocolate are just a few of the many assorted flavors. Both the strawberry rhubarb and black raspberry were scrumptious, but you can't go wrong with any of these divine flavors.

The Barn

First grab a cider slushie, some kettle corn or a fry pie and then meander through the outdoor area, where you will find furniture, whiskey barrels, and signs spread out for you to shop.

Head inside the large barn filled with quality made items. Allow ample time to browse the barn filled with Amish built pieces from handcrafted signs, sturdy furniture, knives, leather goods, and wooden toys. These quality built items will stand the test of time. There is something for everyone at Herberger’s Farm.

Hand crafted items

Petting Farm

For an additional fee, explore the Petting Farm, where you’ll be surrounded by goats, chickens, bunnies, horses, and pigs. Certain times of year, you can even enjoy a ride on the Big Horse and view the farm on a buggy ride. It’s a unique experience for the whole family as you pet and feed furry friends. Check their Facebook page for additional information.

• Winter Hours 10am- 4pm (Nov-Dec) (March-April)

• Summer Hours 9am- 5pm (May-Sept)

• Closed Sundays

• Fee: Tickets $6.00 per person

• Special Christmas Kid’s Day: Dec 16, 2023

Closing Thoughts

Hershberger’s Farm is the perfect place to witness the best of Amish living. It’s one of the best things to do in Northeast, Ohio for families. This working farm has a bakery offering fresh items daily, a petting farm and large barn filled with quality Amish goods. Whether you are stopping to grab fresh produce, visiting furry friends at the petting farm, or are looking to find that hand-crafted gift for your friend or family member, you won't leave empty handed when visiting Herberger’s.

We’d love to know what are your favorite things to do in Northeastern, Ohio. Follow Discovering Anew for more Midwest travel destinations. Make sure to pin and save for later and share with a friend.

Featured Posts You May Enjoy

Outdoor Gift Ideas for Kids

Fun Winter Activities for Kids

Best Michigan State Parks for Kids